The Truth About New South Windows: What You’re Not Being Told

🔍 Who Is New South Windows, Really?

New South Windows (also known as New South Window Solutions) advertises itself as a Florida-based window manufacturer—“made in America, crafted for Florida homes,” they claim. Their website shows photos of a large Tampa factory, and reps often tout being "factory-direct," suggesting they're producing windows locally.

But here's the deal—according to insiders on Reddit and public records, that Tampa "factory" closed years ago. New South no longer manufactures windows there; it’s now just a warehouse. The windows themselves are reportedly manufactured out of state, in places like Texas or even by PGT-owned facilities (reddit.com).

So while they say they "make their own windows," New South is essentially a sales organization that sources parts globally (likely vinyl, hardware, and glass from major suppliers) and brands them as “New South.”

🏗️ They Don’t Install Them Themselves

You might think the people who sell your windows are also going to install them. Not with New South. Like many big brands, they use independent subcontractors to handle installations.

That means your install crew might:

• Show up with minimal supervision from New South HQ
• Vary in experience and reliability
• Be liable for shipping errors, mismatched parts, or installation delays—issues that have popped up repeatedly in their reviews (bbb.org).

In Florida—where proper flashing and impact-rated installations are critical—this inconsistency can lead to leaks, failed inspections, and call-backs down the road.

📜 The Warranty Isn’t as Good as It Sounds

On paper, New South offers a “Real Lifetime, Non‑Prorated Parts & Labor Warranty.” Sounds amazing, right?

But the devil lurks in the details:

1. Full coverage only if you pay in full upfront—which many homeowners do, then later discover issues (bbb.org).
2. Lifetime applies only while you're the original homeowner—no transferability if you sell your house.
3. Acts of God or installation faults are excluded—so if a storm damages a window, don’t expect free repairs.
4. “Lifetime” often capped at 30–40 years max, per clause—despite flashy marketing.
5. Labor coverage is limited by subcontractor availability, and tracking down that help can be a headache according to multiple complaints (newsouthwindow.com, guildquality.com, bbb.org).

Translated: it's less “unlimited” and more “limited while not inconvenient for us.”

🧾 What Customers Are Actually Saying

Let’s dive into real reviews across platforms to see why New South’s pristine image isn’t matching reality:

1. Trustpilot – 2.5 Stars, “Poor” Rating

• “Great sales guy, zero follow-up. Half my windows don’t work three years later—no help.” (ca.trustpilot.com)
• “We signed contract in June; no permit applied, no install scheduled six months later.” (ca.trustpilot.com)

2. BBB – 91 Complaints in 3 Years

• “Wrong window installed, screens missing for six months after paid in full.” (bbb.org)
• “Door installed crooked, drywall damaged, unexpected $600 charge.” (bbb.org)
• “One-third deposit taken, then they backed out and won't refund it.”

3. Yelp – Mixed Reviews in Tampa/Orlando

• “Windows and installers great, communication is a D+. They lie. Not locally owned.” (yelp.com)
• Altamonte Springs: “Communication terrible outside of sales.” (yelp.com)
• Tampa: “We couldn’t be happier”—but these bright reviews are far outnumbered by complaints elsewhere (newsouthwindow.com).

4. Angi – 1-Star Complaints

• “Picture windows left black insulation exposed like ants crawling—no follow-up for weeks.” (angi.com)

5. Consumer Affairs – Warranty Praise, Communication Critique

• “Lifetime warranty as manufacturer.” But reviewer complaints focus on lack of follow-up and poor service.

6. Reddit – Sales Tactics Called Out

• Users report high-pressure tactics, exaggerated energy savings, and hidden pricing games (reddit.com).

📝 Common Complaints Across Platforms

Across review sites, one consistent theme emerges: communication breakdowns and installation inconsistencies. Customers report getting strong initial sales experiences but little to no follow-up afterward. Many say that after paying a deposit—or even the full balance—they're left in limbo, waiting for permits to be applied or the install scheduled. Complaints also highlight issues with install quality: crooked doors, damaged drywall, and missing screens or insulation. What’s worse is that warranty coverage often becomes a bureaucratic dead end, as service requires subcontractor scheduling that never materializes. Finally, many reviewers describe intense “high-pressure” sales tactics, complete with unattractive add-ons and confusing quotes once paperwork is signed.

🧢 Why They Keep Using the “We Make Our Own Windows” Line

New South continues to promote a local manufacturing identity for several reasons:

1. Sales leverage: “Factory-direct” messaging helps justify their premium pricing.
2. Perception management: Customers often equate local production with better quality.
3. Obscuring sourcing: Closing out-of-state or offshore production facilities makes it harder to verify where windows actually come from.

But without that Tampa factory and with ownership changes (PGT then MI-TrE brands), New South is really just a branded dealer for another manufacturer’s parts (reddit.com).

👥 The Subcontractor Install Model

Many unhappy reviews trace back to installation issues—but the installers are technically independent. That means:

• 🌱 Varying quality control depending on subcontractor skill
• 🛠️ Delayed warranty service due to availability
• 🔍 Confusion over responsibility—New South or the third party?

When installs go wrong, you might be calling New South, then chasing the subcontractor, then chasing parts, and then dealing with warranty protocols. That’s a headache homeowners didn’t budget for.

🛑 Warning Signs to Watch

If you're considering New South, keep an eye out for these red flags:

• They push for next-day signings and steep discount deadlines—classic FOMO tactics.
• Their factory claims are unsupported—ask for proof or a plant tour.
• Large deposits taken before permits are even filed.
• Communication drops off after the sale—no callbacks, no scheduling.
• Warranty service depends on third-party subcontractors—which can cost you time and frustration.

💡 What You Should Do Instead

If you’re shopping for windows, here’s a tip:

• Go with a fully transparent local company that handles installation directly or uses vetted, consistent teams
• Ask to see their manufacturing facility or get details on where parts are sourced
• Ensure they offer transferable lifetime warranties, not tied only to the original buyer
• Read balanced reviews on BBB, Yelp, Trustpilot, Angi—don’t just rely on the company’s site
• Go with reputable brands like Eastern Architectural, Simonton, PGT, or Viwinco through local dealers like Windoor Retro Professionals

😊 Final Take

New South presents itself with slick marketing—“factory-direct,” lifetime warranties, polished salespeople—but the truth is more complicated. They:

• Don’t manufacture in Florida anymore
• Use subcontracted installers of varying reliability
• Have warranty limitations and long delays
• Receive serious customer service red flags across multiple platforms
• Use high-pressure sales tactics to secure deals

While they do install quality windows if you get lucky, the overall consumer experience doesn’t align with the image they project. If you're in Ocala, Tampa, Orlando, or anywhere in Florida, you deserve transparent practices, dependable service, and honest warranties.

At Windoor Retro Professionals, we offer:

• No-pressure consultations
• In-house local installation teams
• Clear sourcing and transferable warranties
• Reputable, verified Florida-tested window brands
• Transparent pricing and reliable post-sales support

—

📞 Don’t gamble on uncertain promises—choose clarity, quality, and local support. Contact Windoor Retro Professionals today for a free consultation on windows and doors built for Florida.