The Truth About New South Windows: What You’re Not Being Told

Joe Underwood • June 30, 2025

Uncovering Where They Really Source Their Windows, How Their Installs Work, and Why the Warranty May Leave You Out in the Cold

New South Window Solutions promotes itself as a Florida-based window manufacturer—“made in America, crafted for Florida homes.” Their website features factory photos in Tampa and reps frequently claim they're "factory-direct," suggesting local production.

But here’s what the evidence shows:

According to Reddit insiders, the Tampa “factory” closed years ago and is now just a warehouse. Production reportedly moved to Texas or PGT-owned facilities following ownership changes in 2020 and 2024 Yelp Reddit.
Reddit users noted New South reps assert “factory-direct” superiority, but others shared that manufacturing happens out of state Reddit+1 Reddit+1.

In short, while they promote themselves as manufacturers, New South is primarily a branding and sales organization sourcing parts globally (vinyl, hardware, glass), then labeling them as its own.

🏗️ They Don’t Install Them Themselves

Like many big-box window providers, New South relies entirely on subcontracted contractors to install windows.

That means:

Install crews may arrive with minimal oversight from New South HQ
Quality and professionalism can vary widely
Responsibility for errors—shipping mistakes, missing parts, botched installs—falls on third parties

A BBB listing for their Altamonte Springs location, for example, flags dozens of service complaints about crooked doors, drywall damage, and surprise charges Better Business Bureau+7 Reddit+7 Replacement Windows Reviews+7 Reddit+13 Better Business Bureau+13 Better Business Bureau+13 Replacement Windows Reviews. In Florida’s tough climate, such inconsistencies can easily translate to leaks, failed inspections, and frustrating callbacks for homeowners.

📜 The Warranty Isn’t as Good as It Sounds

Their marketing touts a “Real Lifetime, Non‑Prorated Parts & Labor Warranty”—but here’s where reality bites:

Full coverage only if paid in full upfront, which many homeowners later regret Better Business Bureau+1 Better Business Bureau+1
Warranty often applies only while you're the original owner—no transfer if you sell
Acts of God and installation errors are explicitly excluded
“Lifetime” coverage often capped at 30–40 years, per contract clauses (reviewed by consumer advocates) Reddit+5 Replacement Windows Reviews+5 Reddit+5
Labor claims depend on subcontractor availability—and as BBB records show, getting service arranged can take months Reddit+5 Better Business Bureau+5 Better Business Bureau+5

In other words: less “unlimited support,” more “good luck if things go south.”

🧾 What Customers Are Actually Saying

A look across public review sites shows a consistent pattern:

Trustpilot (2.5★ “Poor”)
“Great sales guy, zero follow-up. Half my windows don’t work three years later—no help.”
“No permit applied, no install scheduled six months later.” Reddit+1 Reddit+1
BBB (91 complaints in 3 years)
Reports include missing screens, crooked doors, drywall damage, and withheld deposits Better Business Bureau Better Business Bureau.
**Yelp (Tampa/Orlando)**
Mixed reviews:
“Great windows and installers, but communication is a D+. Not locally owned.”
Others cite poor post-sales support Yelp+12 Reddit+12 Reddit+12 Reddit+3 Replacement Windows Reviews+3 Better Business Bureau+3.
Consumer Affairs
Users praise the warranty but criticize sales tactics and lack of follow-through Reddit.
Reddit
Community members note aggressive sales strategies and tall energy-efficiency claims Replacement Windows Reviews.

📝 Common Complaints Across Platforms

What emerges consistently:

High-pressure sales pitches, steep “today-only” discounts
Long delays or disappearing communication after deposits are made
Installation issues—crooked doors, drywall damage, missing parts
Warranty claims turning into bureaucratic hang-ups, especially due to subcontractor bottlenecks

🧢 Why They Keep Saying “We Make Our Own Windows”

The messaging serves multiple goals:

Justifies premium pricing with perceived factory-direct advantage
Gives an impression of local production and quality control
Obscures sourcing by emphasizing legacy facilities, despite closures Better Business Bureau

In reality, post-PGT acquisition and PGT/Mi-TrE restructuring, New South operates more like a branded dealer than a manufacturer Better Business Bureau+6 Reddit+6 Replacement Windows Reviews+6.

👥 The Subcontractor Install Model

Because installations are subcontracted:

Quality control varies based on the installer hired
Warranty service depends on availability of the subcontractor
Accountability becomes murky—Is it New South or your installer who’s responsible?

When things go sideways, you could be ping-ponging between New South, your subcontractor, and parts suppliers—all while craving service.

🛑 Warning Signs to Watch

If considering New South, be cautious of:

Urgency to sign next-day deals or steep deadlines
Factory claims without verification or tours
Requesting large deposits pre-permits
Repeating communication drop-off after the sale
Warranty coverage that depends on subcontractor scheduling

💡 What You Should Do Instead

Choose a transparent local company that installs with its own vetted team
Ask for proof of manufacturing facilities or documents about sourcing
Ensure transferrable lifetime warranties not tied to you only
Use review sites—BBB, Yelp, Trustpilot, Angi—to spot patterns, not just star ratings
Consider brands known for quality—Eastern Architectural, Simonton, PGT, Viwinco—through local dealers like Windoor Retro Professionals

😊 Final Take

New South markets a sleek image—“factory-direct,” lifetime warranties, strong salespeople—but the data tells a more complicated story:

They no longer manufacture in Florida, operating as a distributor instead
Installers are contracted, with service quality that varies widely
Warranty coverage is limited and bureaucratic, often excluding key scenarios
Customer service red flags appear consistently across platforms
Sales tactics can be overly aggressive and confusing

Yes, if everything aligns you might get a good install. But the risk of warranty issues, delays, and poor communication is significant—and well documented.

✅ What We Do at Windoor Retro Professionals

In-house licensed installers—no subcontractor roulette
Clear sourcing—you see the window’s origin and specs
Transferable lifetime warranty—backed by us, not just suppliers
Transparent pricing, no pressure sales
Prompt post-install service, not just polite apologies

We serve Ocala, Gainesville, Tampa, Orlando, St. Pete, Crystal River, Inverness, Citrus Springs, Homosassa, Hernando, and nearby counties—delivering windows and doors built for Florida’s real world.

📞 Contact us for a no-pressure quote that comes with clarity, expertise, and honesty—no smoke and mirrors.

Sources: